Loyal store customer Mary told us about these nutrition packed, portable cookies. Nutritionally-dense sweet potatoes and whole grains are combined with anti-inflammatory spices from British Cake Spice. Oh, and they’re delicious, too! Bake these, tuck them in the freezer then grab one on your way out. Our new favorite breakfast. Thanks Mary! Adapted from Run Fast...
Sweet and salty. A sugar-studded crunchy bite. All with a umami edge. A tiny bit of heat. These cookies really deliver. The rich miso adds tons of depth taking this class PB cookie to new, adventurous places. Ginger Sugar encases the cookies for the perfect zing. Perfect for a cookie swap. A must for a...
This fun twist on classic crinkle cookies melds rich espresso with our Chai Spice. The bold, aromatic dough is rolled in powdered sugar so that they crackle and crumble as they bake. The delightful, spiced exterior encases a soft, pillowy center. Perfect for coffee lovers, cookie lovers and chai lovers. That’s a lot of love!...
Subtly-sweet cookies with a not-so-subtle Halloween vibe. Creepy Witches Finger Cookies are all about adding spooky whimsy to your Halloween party spread. Eerie and lifelike, complete with almond “nails,” you might hesitate in taking a bite, but trust us, once you do, they’re such a treat. No tricks. Our Almond Extract makes for the perfect...
These rich, dark chocolate cookies are bursting with sweet dried cherries. So complex in flavor but a cinch to make. Pre-mix this dough, roll in a log and pop the in the freezer. Each batch slices into 12 cookies – maybe double (or triple) the recipe! When you’re ready to bake, don’t forget to roll...
Our Buzz’d Baking Spice will have you buzzing! Sweet honey plus a caffeine kick from espresso powder makes this baking blend completely unique and full of surprises. We love what Buzz’d Baking Spice does for these simple cookies. Bake a batch!
Spicy, chocolate-y and completely surprising. If you love chiles but you’ve conquered all the salsas, simmered pots of chili and rolled all the pans of enchiladas, meet your next chile conquest. These chocolate-studded, Habanero Sugar coated cookies are sure to please. Gift a batch to your heat-loving friends. They’ll be knocking on your door for...
Best part of this absolutely perfect cookie? It’s a great blank canvas. Roll in any sugar! Coffee lovers should try our Vanilla Latte Sugar or Espresso Sugar. These are divine rolled in Lemon or Ginger Sugar. For a seasonal flair, try Pumpkin Spice Sugar. In this recipe, we rolled them in our Sweet N Salty...
Chewy interiors. Crispy edges. Crunchy, lemony sugar topping. These cookies are all that. Big beautiful lemon flavor from fresh zest plus Lemon Sugar. Such a sweet treat!
Store owner Anne is all about a retro recipe. So much so, she wallpapered a wall with vintage recipes in the Teaching Kitchen at Red Stick Spice! Anne stumbled on this spice cookie recipe, originally called Elevator Lady Cookies, and she knew she had to give them a try. Gingerbread Spice subs in for the...